Running your own business is exciting. But somewhere between chasing invoices, serving clients, and trying to actually enjoy your life, the question creeps in: do I really need an accountant, or can I just handle this myself?
It's a fair question — and the honest answer is: it depends. Here's a clear-eyed guide to help you decide.
What does an accountant actually do for a sole trader?
At the most basic level, an accountant will:
- Prepare and file your self-assessment tax return
- Make sure you're claiming every allowable expense
- Keep you compliant with HMRC deadlines
- Advise you on how to structure your finances tax-efficiently
But a good accountant does more than just compliance. They act as a financial sounding board — someone who can tell you whether that piece of equipment is worth buying before the tax year ends, or whether you're better off registering for VAT voluntarily.
When you can probably manage without one
There are situations where going it alone is perfectly reasonable:
- Your income is straightforward. If you have one source of self-employment income, no rental properties, no investments, and no complex expenses, your tax return is unlikely to be complicated.
- You're comfortable with numbers. If you're happy using HMRC's online portal and you understand the basics of allowable expenses, you may be able to file accurately yourself.
- Your income is low. If you're in the early stages and earning below the personal allowance (£12,570 for 2026/27), your tax liability may be minimal.
When you should seriously consider an accountant
The calculation changes quickly once any of the following apply:
- You're turning over more than £30,000–£40,000 a year. At this level, the tax savings an accountant can identify typically outweigh their fees many times over.
- You have multiple income sources. Employment income, freelance work, rental income, dividends — each adds complexity and risk of errors.
- You're spending hours on admin. Your time has a value. If bookkeeping and tax prep are eating into billable hours, the maths often favour outsourcing.
- You've received a letter from HMRC. Don't face an enquiry alone.
- You're unsure what you can claim. This is one of the most common — and costly — mistakes sole traders make. Underestimating expenses means overpaying tax.
- You're thinking about going limited. If you're considering incorporating, you need professional advice first.
The hidden cost of getting it wrong
Many sole traders assume the cost of an accountant is the main consideration. But the cost of not having one can be higher:
- Missed deductions add up fast. A sole trader missing just £3,000 in legitimate expenses pays an extra £600–£900 in tax (depending on their rate).
- Late filing penalties start at £100 and escalate quickly.
- HMRC errors are difficult and stressful to resolve without professional support.
What does it actually cost?
For a straightforward sole trader self-assessment, you should expect to pay anywhere from £200–£600 per year for a one-off return. Monthly packages that include bookkeeping, VAT, and ongoing support typically start from around £80–£150 per month depending on complexity.
Framed differently: if an accountant saves you £1,000 in tax and charges you £400, you're £600 better off and you've reclaimed the hours you'd have spent staring at HMRC's website.
The bottom line
You don't legally need an accountant as a sole trader. But for most people running a business with any meaningful turnover, the combination of tax savings, time saved, and peace of mind makes it well worth the cost.
If you're on the fence, most accountants — including us — offer a free initial consultation. There's no obligation, and it'll give you a clear picture of whether professional help makes sense for your situation.
Think you might benefit from some support?